Friday, May 7, 2010

A Movie Smart and With Heart: The Secret in Their Eyes (El Secreto De Sus Ojos)

It won the Oscar for best foreign film this year.

The Internet Movie Database lists it as a Crime, Drama, Mystery, Romance, Thriller.

This is accurate.

Humor is something else that is abundant throughout, but it's not a comedy.

The romance and the humor offset a dark story based around the solving of a gruesome murder. The darkness balances the yearning of a love story that is tender and true and so rare on a big screen, particularly for how much it has you wanting to see it work, wonder if it will work (I won't tell you). I never thought the phrase 'It'll have you rooting for X' in a movie could be taken sincerely (thought it was reserved for Sandra Bullock vehicles). It can when the main characters have this much humanity.

He's a man of great integrity. I fell in love with her.

Though not a true story, its filled with detail that makes the lives of these people, the place they work, their homes, the bars they hang out in all feel real, but yet its not so real as to be arty (in the incomprehensible or banal senses of the word). Thought made in Argentina, the movie still has that stuff of the mythic that Hollywood is so good at, the stuff that raises a narrative above the everyday, that magic stuff we wanted before we went to sleep as kids (and still want, no?)

"The Secret in Their Eyes" won't be in theatres (for those lucky enough to even have it in theatres close to home) much longer. It may not be a perfect movie, but it's well worth the price of admission.


  1. Anonymous11:45 a.m.

    Haven't seen this, but want to check it out. Couple of other great foreign films i've seen recently...

    Girl with the Dragon Tatoo - Swedish murder mystery. Really fun stuff with great characters. Book is better, as it always is...i think i'm enjoying the 2nd book even more, but you can stream this movie online.

    - A Prophet - Sort of an art house prison scarface. French film. Intense but very good. (also streamable..god bless the internet)


  2. Gonna see A Prophet for sure. Want to catch it at a rep theatre. Also, probably Girl with Dragon Tattoo.

    God bless the internet? I don't know. If we keep expecting all creative content to be free...


Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.

Follow mendelsohnjon on Twitter